09 Deadly Twins of the Mushroom World
Mushroomsβ similarity is not accidental.From an evolutionary perspective, this involves multiple mechanisms.Convergent evolution has enabled different species to develop similar morphology in similar ecological niches.For example, the umbrella appearance is actually one of the most effective spore-transmissive structures and is therefore independently evolved by a variety of irrelevant mushrooms.
More complexity is that many mushrooms we once thought were single species actually contain multiple "hidden species".Modern DNA analysis technology has overturned traditional classification systems.For example, "death caps" in North America may actually contain several populations with significant genetic differences, which look almost the same, but may have slightly different toxicity.
Our brains are used to fast pattern recognition, which is often an effective survival skill in nature.But in mushroom identification, this ability may become a fatal weakness.We tend to focus on conspicuous featuresβcolor, size, overall shapeβand ignore those tiny but critical identification features.
On the field trip I had led, at least three collectors who claimed to be "ten years of experience" almost ate the Angel of Destruction because they did not check the base of the mushrooms.Human attention is limited, and mushroom identification requires systematic and comprehensive examination.
In 2018, a Vietnamese immigrant family in California collected straw mushrooms they believed were common in their hometowns.As a result, these were death caps, resulting in the death of two people and the liver injury of three people required transplantation.Forensic mycological analysis showed that if they examined the spore marks, the tragedy could be completely avoided.
- Variable colours of caps: from yellow-green to olive green, and may even be white or brown
- The tuck is always pure white, free (not connected to the tuck)
- The stem has obvious and long-lasting white bacteria rings
- The most critical feature: obvious white cystic tray wrapped around the base of the mushroom
- Smell: No obvious odor or slightly sweet when young, similar to rose fragrance
1. Spore printing test (most reliable method)
- Remove the cap and place it on half-white and half-black paper (or glass), cover the cup and let it sit for 2-6 hours
- Death Cap: Pure White Spore Print
- Straw mushroom: pink spore printing
- Expert tip: Carry spore paper with you and you can test it in the wild
2. Base Inspection Technology
- Dig out the mushrooms intact and do not cut them off on the ground
- Use your fingers to gently brush the soil and leaves around the base
- The bacterial holder of the death cap may be fragile and fragile and should be handled with caution
3. Nine Analysis
- Death cap forms mycorrhizal relationship with oak and chestnut trees, and always grows under the tree
- Straw mushrooms usually grow on straw piles or compost and do not rely on specific trees
If you find mushrooms with both rings, troughs and white pleats, immediately consider them as potentially deadly unless you are a professional mycologist.
A mushroom hunter with 15 years of experience collected white mushrooms in Montana what he considered an edible ponyball.He did not check the base because puffballs usually have no obvious stems.The result was the Angel of Destruction, who was lucky enough to survive but experienced three weeks of organ failure and treatment.
- Full white appearance, pure and harmless
- Contains amanitotoxin similar to death caps, extremely toxic
- The fungus trough may be completely covered with deciduous leaves or soil and must be carefully excavated
- Separate mushrooms: The puffball inside is uniform, solid white or turns yellow and pink as it matures; the angel of Destruction has differentiated into caps, folds and stalk structures
- The puffball will turn brown spore powder inside when it matures; the angel of Destruction keeps white tissue
- Mushroom species sterile tracts - This is the key difference
- The mushroom genus has changed from pink to chocolate brown as it matures
- Spore Print: Mushroom is chocolate brown; Destruction Angel is white
- Oyster mushrooms are usually laterally grown or without typical stalks, growing on dead trees
- Oyster mushroom sterile ring, sterile tray
- Carry a small outdoor shovel for complete excavation of mushrooms
- Observe base details using a handheld magnifying glass (10x)
- Prepare spore paper of various colors (white, black, gray) to suit different spore colors
A professional chef collected morels on his own in Oregon, and ended up mixing a small amount of fake morels.Five customers he served were hospitalized for severe food poisoning, and his restaurant also faced legal action.
- Unique honeycomb cover with regular arrangement of pits
- The edge of the cap is completely connected to the stem
- The interior is completely hollow, from the top of the cap to the base of the stem
- Contains methylhydrazine, which is the ingredient of rocket fuel
- Toxicity varies from person to person, some people may show tolerance, but the risk is extremely high
- Cooking can only partially reduce toxicity and cannot be completely removed
1. Structural Inspection Method
- Real morels: The cap looks like a regular beehive, the ridge is solid
- Fake morel: The cap is irregular in brain-like folds, like walnut kernels
2. Connection point analysis
- Real morels: The edge of the cap is completely fused with the top of the stalk
- Fake morel: The cap "sits" on the stalk like a hat, and the connection is not complete
3. Internal inspection
- Longitudinal cut mushrooms: real morels are completely hollow; fake morels have cotton-like substances in the stems
Even for confirmed real morels, it is recommended to try in small quantities first, as some individuals may have sensitive reactions to even edible fungi species.
- Golden yellow appearance and unique apricot scent
- Thick, bifurcated pseudo-fungus folds
- Solid and slightly fibrous texture
- There are real bacteria folds, thin and sharp, and not easy to split
- The color is orange and the center is usually darker
- Soft texture, lacking the firmness of chanterelles
- In total darkness, the bacterial folds of fresh specimens emit a faint green light
- Always grow in clusters on wood, with bases connected
- Causes severe gastrointestinal poisoning
1. Bacteria fold test
- Gently try isolate the pleats with the tip of the knife: the pseudo-fungal folds of chanterelles are difficult to separate; the funo-fungal folds of chanterelles are easy to separate
- Rub the folds of bacteria with your fingers: The pseudo-bacteria of chanterelles feels like wax; pseudo-bacteria feels more fragile
2. Growth Mode Observation
- Chanterelles usually grow single or small groups in the soil
- Jack Lantern Mushrooms always grow on wood
3. Smell identification
- Chanterelles have a distinct fruit aroma
- Imitators usually have no obvious odor or only have regular mushroom flavor
- Most boletus is edible, with important exceptions
- Usually there are spongy pore layers instead of bacterial folds
- Many kinds of color change when injured
- The cap is grayish white to olive color
- The orifices are bright red, almost blood-red
- The stem is thick and has red mesh patterns
- The cut surface may change slightly blue or not change color
- Non-toxic but extremely bitter, a small piece can ruin the whole pot of soup
- The orifices are pink when mature
- The stem has dark reticle
- This test is only performed on mushrooms that have been initially confirmed to be safe
- Take a small chunk of sterilization edge and chew for 5-10 seconds but don't swallow
- Spit out immediately and rinse your mouth if there is any bitter, spicy or abnormal taste.
- This test is only used to confirm edible species and cannot be used to exclude toxic species
1. Growth Environment Analysis
- Record the types of trees around (hardwood, conifer)
- Observe growth matrix (soil, wood, feces)
- Pay attention to the growth method of mushrooms (single, group, clustered)
2. Complete Collection
- Use a spatula to dig out completely to ensure that the base structure is not damaged
- Keep specimens from different maturity stages
3. Macro feature record
- Cap shape, color, surface characteristics (slimy, dry, scales)
- Color, density, and attachment method of bacterial folds/orifices
- Characteristics of stalks (whether there are rings, reticles, scales)
- Base characteristics (whether there are troughs or root-like extensions)
4. Fresh Feature Test
- Color change reaction: Cut or extrude to observe color changes
- Milk check: Whether there is milk secretion and how the color changes
- Odor Record: The smell of fresh cut surfaces
5. Spore printing production
- This is one of the most reliable identification features
- Portable spore printing tool kit can be used in the wild
- Record the color, density and texture of spore prints
6. Microscopic feature verification (advanced)
- Observe spore shape and size using a portable microscope
- Professional identification may require more complex microstructure analysis
7. Multi-resource cross-validation
- Use at least three independent identification resources
- Refer to the latest guide from local fungi societies
8. Final Safety Assessment
- Do all traits consistently point to the same species?
- Have all possible dangerous similar species been ruled out?
- If you have any uncertainty, follow the principle of "disclaim if you doubt"
Once we believe we have found some kind of edible mushroom, the brain unconsciously searches for evidence supporting this conclusion while ignoring the contradictory information.
Use the "blind identification" method - let your companions remove your initial judgment and check each feature again from scratch, just like the first time you see this mushroom.
After several successful identifications, the collector is prone to developing dangerous self-confidence.A mycologist I knew was hospitalized after 30 years of safe collection.
When someone on the team claims that "I've eaten this many times, no problem", many people choose to obey even if they have doubts.
Adhere to the principle of personal responsibility - everyone must personally confirm the identity of each mushroom and do not accept verbal guarantees from others.
- A knife with sharp blade
- Small excavation shovel or mud knife
- Spore paper of various colors (white, black, gray)
- Handheld magnifying glass (10x)
- Paper bags or wax paper for packing specimens
- Global Positioning System Record Collection Location
- Digital cameras record fresh status
- A regional mushroom guide with at least two different authors
- Use multiple mushroom identification applications, but only as a helper
- Join the local fungi society to participate in field trips and workshops
- Subscribe to the latest mycologic research newsletter
- Portable microscope (400x)
- Chemical kit (for specific color reaction tests)
- DNA sampling toolkit (for molecular identification of difficult species)
An immigrant from China collected mushrooms similar to the edible fungi in his hometown in the Pacific Northwest.He did not realize that the death cap had been introduced into the region from Europe and was extremely similar to the species he was familiar with.As a result, the whole family was poisoned and one person died.
Lesson: When moving to a new environment, local mushrooms must be re-learned and cannot rely on knowledge of their country of origin.
A mycologic teacher with 20 years of experience mistakenly collected fake morels as real morels in a field course.Fortunately, the abnormality was discovered by students before cooking.
Lesson: Even if you have rich experience, you must systematically check each feature and cannot be judged intuitively.
One collector correctly identified the chanterelles but ignored the small amount of Jack Lantern mushrooms mixed in it.Although it is not fatal, it has caused severe gastrointestinal discomfort in the whole family and is hospitalized.
Lesson: Each mushroom must be checked one by one for each collection, and you cannot relax your vigilance because most of them are correct.
1. Absolute Rules
- Never rely on a single identification feature
- Always dig out the mushrooms intact check base
- Always make spore prints for uncertain mushrooms
- Never eat raw mushrooms (many edible types are toxic to eat raw)
2. Learning Path Suggestions
- Year 1: Only 5 absolutely safe "beginner mushrooms" are collected
- Year 2: Add 3-5 new types under the guidance of experts
- Years 3 to 5: gradually expand knowledge, but only a few new species are added each year
- Continuing Education: Regularly attend advanced courses even if you are experienced
3. Emergency Preparation
- Carry emergency contact information with you
- Tell others about your collection location and estimated return time
- Keep samples of each collected species in case of poisoning and need identification
- Learn about the recent Poison Control Center contact information
In the world of mushroom collection, the most dangerous thing is often not the mushroom itself, but the overconfidence of the collector.After 25 years of research and field work, I still remain awe and cautious about every identification.
Remember these principles:
- Systematic multiple feature confirmation is the only reliable method
- "Discard doubts and abandons them" is not timidity, but a reflection of professional qualities
- Every successful identification is worth celebrating, but every time you give up when you are uncertain, you deserve more respect
The world of mushrooms is full of wonder and deliciousness, but also hides fatal risks.Through knowledge, systems and continuous prudence, we can safely enjoy this gift given by nature.
Finally Suggestion: No mushroom meal is worth taking a life adventure.When suspicious, throw it away.Missing a delicious opportunity will always come again, but accidentally eating a deadly mushroom may not have a second chance.
May every outdoor collection be full of discoveries and guarantees of safe return.
1. Life safety first: There are inherent risks in the identification of wild mushrooms.Many toxic mushrooms look very similar to edible mushrooms, and accidentally ingesting them can lead to serious illness or even death.
2. Professional identification required: Before eating any wild mushrooms, 100% confirmation must be performed by a professional mycologist or certified mushroom identification expert.Photos, text descriptions and personal experience are not sufficient to ensure safety.
3. Individual Differences: Even recognized edible mushrooms may cause adverse reactions due to factors such as personal constitution, allergic reactions, consumption method or mushroom growth environment.Try in small quantities when eating a new variety for the first time.
4. Geographical differences: There are huge differences in mushroom species and toxicity in different regions.The information mentioned in this article may not apply to your region.Please consult local mycology experts and authoritative organizations.
5. Professional Responsibility: The author and the publisher shall not be liable for any direct or indirect damage, disease or loss arising from the use of the information in this article.
- β Participate in formal mushroom identification training courses
- β Join the local mycology association or mushroom club
- β Purchase cultivated mushrooms from reliable sources
- β Save mushroom samples for emergency medical needs
- β Do not eat it if you have any doubts